H.R. 2289 – A Congressional Bill That Strips Local Power by Removing Environmental and Historic Review and Greenlighting Massive Cell Tower Expansion

H.R. 2289 – A Congressional Bill That Strips Local Power by Removing Environmental and Historic Review and Greenlighting Massive Cell Tower Expansion

Download our Factsheet on H.R. 2289

Strong opposition to H.R. 2289

“These bills represent an unprecedented federal intrusion into established local decision-making processes, favoring large broadband, telecommunications, wireless, and cable companies at the expense of residents and taxpayers. These bills strip local governments of the ability to effectively manage the infrastructure built on local streets and in neighborhoods, while imposing no reciprocal obligations on providers.”

As currently drafted, H.R. 278 [included in H.R. 2298] would expand federal control over public power utility infrastructure in Alabama, creating serious safety concerns without any assurance that purported “savings” would be passed on to customers. While public power utilities strongly support expanding broadband access, I do not believe this legislation will achieve that objective.

“As currently drafted, H.R. 278 [ included in H.R. 2289] would expand federal control over public power utility infrastructure, creating serious safety concerns without any assurance that purported “savings” would be passed on to customers.” 

As currently drafted, Section 102 of H.R. 2289 (H.R. 278) would expand federal control over public power utility infrastructure, creating serious safety concerns without any assurance that purported “savings” would be passed on to customers.

“While public power utilities strongly support expanding broadband access, we do not believe this legislation will achieve that objective. As currently drafted, H.R. 278 [included in H.R. 2289] would expand federal control over public power utility infrastructure, undermining local authority and engineering safety without any assurance that purported ‘savings’ would be passed on to customers.” 

“Our members remain committed to supporting broadband deployment, but we do not believe the provisions in Section 102 of H.R. 2289 will advance that goal…As currently drafted, H.R. 278 [ in H.R. 2289] would expand federal control over public power utility infrastructure, creating serious safety concerns without any assurance that purported ‘savings’ would be passed on to customers. While public power utilities strongly support expanding broadband access, we do not believe this legislation will achieve that objective.”

“Imposing federally mandated timelines and deemed-granted provisions, as envisioned in H.R. 278 [included in H.R. 2289], would shift risk and cost to electric customers and undermine utilities’ ability to meet safety, engineering, and staffing requirements. 

Our members remain committed to supporting broadband deployment, some partner directly with providers or operate broadband networks themselves, but we do not believe the provisions in Section 102 of H.R. 2289 will advance that goal. Instead, they would preempt local authority and reduce the tools public power utilities need to manage their systems responsibly.”

Here’s What H.R. 2289 Would Do

1. Sweeping Preemption of Local Control

The Result: Local communities will lose meaningful power to decide on changes to wireless sites based on a transparent and adequate review process.

2. Environmental and Historic Review Rollbacks

H.R. 2289 effectively removes review under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) for “eligible facilities requests,” allowing many modifications and expansions of existing wireless infrastructure to proceed without environmental and historic review. This change substantially weakens protections for a broad range of wireless deployments, from cell towers to 5G, 6G, and beyond.

The Result: Projects move forward without adequate environmental, cultural, or historic protections.

3. Extremely Short Deadlines Render Local Review a Rubber Stamp

The bill imposes extremely short deadlines for processing cell tower and wireless facility applications and automatically approves (“deems granted”) applications if a city misses them. That means building, electrical, encroachment, environmental, and zoning reviews all must be completed within the same short window. Local governments cannot pause or slow applications, even during high-volume periods.

The Result: Industry receives approvals even when local governments cannot reasonably complete their reviews.

4. Severe Limits on Local Fees

Cities and counties may charge only direct processing costs, not fair market rates or fees for long-term oversight or public impact.

The Result: Local taxpayers absorb costs while industry gains inexpensive access to public property.

5. Expanded Pre-emption for RF Health and Environmental Effects

“No State or local government… may regulate the operation, placement, construction, or modification of personal wireless service facilities on the basis of the environmental effects of radio frequency emissions, to the extent that such facilities… comply with the Commission’s regulations.”
—H.R. 2289 

What This Means:
The Bill states localities cannot consider cell tower RF radiation environmental impacts- which includes human health effects—as long as the wireless facility meets outdated FCC limits for allowable cell tower RF radiation exposure. This preemption applies to both placement and operation, eliminating one of the last remaining avenues for community control.

The Result: Communities cannot address residents’ legitimate health and safety issues or restrict facilities near sensitive areas such as schools, homes or ecologically sensitive areas.

Statement on HR. 2289

by Theodora Scarato, Director of the Wireless and EMF Program at Environmental Health Sciences 

Calling this bill a ‘power grab’ doesn’t go far enough. It’s a historic transfer of decision-making from communities to corporations, with virtually no guardrails, and the costs will be borne entirely by residents. It’s a radical shift that elevates industry speed over public safety and democracy. H.R. 2289 will allow many modifications and expansions of existing cell towers and wireless infrastructure to proceed without adequate environmental and historic oversight.

How can Congress and federal regulators- the FCC- mandate unlimited wireless expansion while simultaneously blocking communities from raising safety concerns, eliminating local oversight, and defunding the very research needed to protect the public and environment? This regulatory quagmire leaves families exposed, voiceless, and without any meaningful path to protection.

What the Public Must Do

The public must demand transparency and accountability before Congress rewrites national wireless policy in this way. Residents should contact their elected officials and speak out locally on the need for environmental, health, and safety protections.  

What Policymakers Must Do

Policymakers must stop H.R. 2289 and reject FCC rules that further weaken local authority. Congress should update RF radiation exposure limits using current science and restore independent research funding. Section 704 of the Telecommunications Act must be amended. Lawmakers must preserve local authority, oversight, historic and environmental safeguards, putting public and environmental safety above industry speed.